- Posts: 981
- Thank you received: 865
Bugs: Recent Topics Paging, Uploading Images & Preview (11 Dec 2020)
Recent Topics paging, uploading images and preview bugs require a patch which has not yet been released.
BGG shutting down Marketplace
This follows bungling on the rollout of a new marketplace (with 9% commissions instead of 3%), which was (in my sense) somewhat popular with buyers but not with sellers. I myself wasn't invited to the closed beta, wherein free shipping was offered as an inducement and as a way to artificially inflate the success of the new venture. That venture collapsed less under pressure from disgruntled users than from the collapse of the developer.
Now the "classic" marketplace is also going away.
In usual BGG fashion, the explanation is functionally nonexistent, and questions, even on the "official" thread, are being carefully constrained.
For a site that's 90% user content and has built itself up over the years on the generosity of "donors," it's rather appalling that they feel as though they can no longer serve the users. It's been speculated that this has a fair bit to do with sales tax data, but one would never know based on how BGG communicates, which still falls into the hobbyist model (if I'm being generous) rather than a robust user community model.
Plus, unless I'm misreading, it looks like all the marketplace ancillaries will be gone, too, which would include price history, price comparator, etc. Those data were invaluable for ascertaining real-world values of items. Admittedly, there were lots of problems with the data, particularly the inability to differentiate bundles from single items easily, but the savvy user could get a lot of info out of that.
Anyway, it's all horseshit.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Official announcement: boardgamegeek.com/thread/2914396/announc...market-shutting-down
Official "answers" thread (limited to nuts-and-bolts questions): boardgamegeek.com/thread/2914393/questio...-market-announcement
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
From what I understand, only payment processors must be burdened with the new tax laws regarding sales of over $600 being reported to the IRS. So PayPal would be the one reporting your income in that way.
However, since BGG takes a commission, it entangles them in the sale - at least, that's what I've seen speculated.
If that's the case, it seems like they could drop their commission and let it exist as is. If they need income to help sustain it, they could make it a premium feature and require a yearly fee or something similar.
I really wonder if this void will result in a new entity popping up. I'm surprised we don't already have a board game user focused e-commerce site.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
I do believe it is the act of running a marketplace that connects sellers to buyers that requires them to ensure the sellers are paying their sales tax. The term of art is being a marketplace facilitator. I suspect that laws written with Amazon and eBay in mind have had some collateral damage here.
I think things will spring up but I doubt any will be dominant and at best they'll be regional players. I've been able to use BGG to buy stuff from the US and across Europe which is once again valuable when you're looking for the obscure.
For folks in the UK, somebody was shilling this last week: www.playon-games.co.uk/ . No idea on if it's good or not but competitors are already in action.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
It's been pretty clear for years that BGG's owners wanted to literally capitalize on this vast wealth of user-created content and peer-to-peer interactions. Not only that, but that they increasingly push buying shit as the official ethos. At a basic level, facilitating peer-to-peer sales of used games works against that in obvious ways.
Few serious people wanted a "modern" e-commerce experience out of the BGG marketplace. For basic peer-to-peer supplemented by private messages, it was fine. Not great, but good enough. To my knowledge, no one said "modern e-commerce experience or nothing."
I sent a PM to Aldie asking for further explanation, not that I expect I'll receive it.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
charlest wrote: However, since BGG takes a commission, it entangles them in the sale - at least, that's what I've seen speculated.
Possible, since ebay did the same thing, even when they were taking Paypal. I got 1099 forms from them and Paypal (for the same transactions) last year, since my state went to the $600 reporting threshold early. It also wouldn't surprise me if lawyers got involved and told them that even if they don't accept commission, the only way to completely insulate themselves, from either the sales taxes or reporting threshold (or both) is to not formally facilitate the actual transaction at all. I'm also guessing the lawyers told them not to talk about it, lest it be seen as admitting they knew there was a potential problem.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
I think its another sign that despite the Kumbaya BGG is just one big happy family that in fact BGG is in fact a BUSINESS. And they are large enough to require lawyers, accountants etc to steer them in directions like the one that probably told them that they were a big enough entity to be required to monitor sales tax, whatever etc etc.
To be fair BGG seems to have downplayed, somewhat. the patron/scrappy company schtick that colored their pleas for "donations" in their early days. A while back someone did some decent speculation/analysis that showed the end of year fundraiser/donation/whatever you call them drives had declined in recent years - but even so, they still estimated that its well over $100K in free money thrown at them.
I had far more crickets chirping than responses the few times I used BGG Marketplace; I think in recent years Facebook has replaced a lot of the secondary market need that BGG used to fulfill - I've had far better luck in FB getting responses, more reasonably priced stuff etc.
The only thing I'll miss from the BGG Marketplace is the pricing history, which was went back far earlier than Ebay, and was far far far easier to find than on Ebay.
In the end run I suspect that the commissions ( or lack thereof ) weren't enough to justify the overhead to collect them.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Sagrilarus
- Offline
- D20
- Pull the Goalie
- Posts: 8739
- Thank you received: 7353
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
I’ll miss the marketplace. I didn’t use it often, but it was great for getting a sense of what is available, how much people are paying for it. It helped me decide on purchases a lot. And I managed to get some really great deals by using the subscription to get notifications.
I also wonder if the individual game message boards will now be flooded with “I have this for sale” posts that will make them less useful over time for people who are there to read and participate in discussions about the actual games.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
My understanding is that the flea market area will just be for people to post games they have for sale, and the entirety of the transaction would occur without BGG direct involvement, including communication, shipping, payment, etc.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
At the time that this ruling went down, I was doing accounting for a rapidly growing software reseller, and the software publisher did not bother with sales territories for the resellers. 80% of our business was in Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Iowa, and we had physical presence in those states, so we were properly charging and remitting sales tax there. The other 20% of business was all across the country, ranging from California to Puerto Rico (which has very unconventional sales tax laws compared to the rest of the U.S.). In some cases, we were required to immediately apply for a state sales tax ID and start reporting. Other states still weren't charging sales tax on e-commerce, but I had to check in on those states every month to see if any of them passed new laws. BGG probably doesn't want any part of that mess.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
It's probably time to bite the bullet and just starting donating. At least I can gain some tax benefit on it, and perhaps someone will get something they want.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
jpat wrote: It's probably time to bite the bullet and just starting donating. At least I can gain some tax benefit on it, and perhaps someone will get something they want.
Bringing new meaning to the next "Let's Donate!" thread.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
The other avenue is NOBLE KNIGHT will buy stuff, giving you store credit or a slightly lower amount in cash. They cover shipping as well. You won't get top dollar of course, but its hard to beat the one stop shopping ( or opposite in this case ) . Their pricing is variable of course; if they have six copies of say CASE BLUE they aren't gonna give you the same value as if your copy was the only one. But its easy and convenient. Good for unpunched/shrink stuff .
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.